Most Surprising Moment… that is hard because there are so many. The first surprising moment I had while watching the show was when we found out Ruby was the big bad wolf and killed the man she loved. The list just goes on and on, but I think the most surprising moment that there has been was when we find out who Peter Pan really is.
I grew up watching Peter Pan as a kid and I was a little surprise that they made him evil on the show. They way that he was talking to Emma gave me chills and then we find out why. He’s Rumpelstiltskin’s father! Watching that caused me to collapse on the floor. I did not see that coming at all. I also didn’t watch the entire episode at first, so I didn’t see that it was focused on Rumple’s father. I walked in when Rumple’s father told him that he had to give him up in order to live on Neverland. My jaw dropped to the floor when his dad transformed back to be a kid and it was Peter Pan.